Greene & Schultz Trial Lawyers
We protect the interests of clients in Indiana and Illinois who have been injured and wronged.
Talk to us about your case. 812-336-4357
View Our Practice Areas

What is Wrong with Mandatory Arbitration

The news story surrounding former FOX News anchor, Gretchen Carlson, has gone viral. She is attempting to sue her former boss and FOX News chairman, Roger Ailes, for sexual harassment. Her case was filed in state court in New York. However, attorneys for Ailes claim that Carlson must abide by an arbitration agreement, which was in her employment contract. Therefore, Carlson may not have a right to a trial by jury.

This may seem like a minor procedural detail, which is exactly what powerful companies and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce want us to believe. After all, arbitration has been around a while. In-and-of-itself, it's not necessarily a bad thing. In fact, when both sides are in agreement to use arbitration, it can help speed along the resolution of a case. I've used arbitration before with clients and will likely use it again in the future.

However, this situation is very different. Carlson may be forced to use arbitration because of a clause in the employment contract she signed with Fox. It's what we refer to as "mandatory arbitration." She was required to agree to it long before she began experiencing the harassment or before the dispute arose. Mandatory arbitration is now very common in all aspects of our lives. These binding mandatory arbitration agreements are being buried into almost every consumer contract out there. They're a part of the "fine print", so to speak. Mandatory arbitration clauses are showing up in bank and credit card agreements, insurance contracts, employment agreements, and even nursing home admission paperwork.

So what's the problem with arbitration, you may be asking? An arbitration is a private judicial proceeding. The arbitrators are paid by the parties. They are not government officials. The problem is that everything in an arbitration proceeding is kept hidden from the public. All information leading to the result of the arbitration will be kept secret. There is no judge, no public record, and no jury.

Our Founding Fathers thought that a right to trial by jury in civil cases was so important that they carved it into stone as the 7th Amendment to the Constitution. It is, literally, in our Bill of Rights. The reason trial by jury in civil cases is so important is that it allows the average person to have equal footing in a dispute with the rich and powerful. An individual has as much standing as General Motors or Bank of America. It keeps people, such as Ailes or any other large and powerful entities, accountable for their actions in a public forum. That is exactly why Roger Ailes and Fox News want arbitration instead of a jury in a court of law. They don't want the public to know how badly they have behaved.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

High Touch, Strong Service, Strong Results in Complex Cases.

Don't Delay! Contact Us for a FREE Consultation and Case Evaluation.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Excellent Representation for the Injured and Their Families.

520 North Walnut Street
Bloomington, IN 47404

Phone: 812-558-0198
Bloomington Law Office Map

450 E. 96th Street
Suite 500
Indianapolis, IN 46240

Toll Free: 866-685-6800
Phone: 812-558-0198
Map & Directions

Contact Us Today

Lawyers with a Wealth of Serious Litigation Experience and Nationwide Teaching and Leadership Abilities.